ibusinesslines.com October 18, 2018

Donald Trump banned from blocking twitter critics, US court decides

24 May 2018, 07:12 | Melissa Porter

Donald Trump banned from blocking twitter critics, US court decides

US judge rules Trump cannot block Twitter critics

A New York District Court judge has ruled that President Donald Trump may not block people on Twitter for criticizing or disagreeing with him.

In her 75-page ruling, U.S. District Court Judge Naomi Buchwald, a Clinton appointee, had suggested that Trump mute rather than block some of his critics. But it could affect the conversation that erupts among supporters and opponents in the replies beneath his tweets.

"This is a great precedent we have set for politicians that decide to use social media as a town hall to be held accountable to the rules of the First Amendment", Gu said.

Blocking the complainants from this public space "based on their political speech constitutes discrimination that violates the First Amendment", wrote the judge. But blocking someone also works in the other direction: if Trump blocks another user, that user can't see Trump's tweets and (as a consequence) can't reply to them.

Twitter's responsibility in policing the public forum was not mentioned in Buchwald's ruling, creating a giant question mark over what specifics should be implemented going forward.

Justice Department attorneys argued that the account was personal and therefore immune to those claims. But, as President, Trump frequently uses it to make official announcements.

Trump, with more than 52 million followers, is the most followed world leader on the micro-blogging site. Rex Tillerson learned he'd been fired from his job as Secretary of State by a tweet from this account, for example.

The White House has not returned a request for comment.

Kerri Kupec, a spokeswoman for the Department of Justice, said in an email: "We respectfully disagree with the court's decision and are considering our next steps".

The Australian Constitution does not explicitly protect free speech.

When Gu was blocked, he said that he didn't feel pride like some Twitter users do when they are blocked.

But being able to comment on a tweet requires following the president - and blocking someone means he or she can not jump in with their thoughts.

"I sued the president, and I won", Ms. Buckwalter Poza said on Twitter. Among them was Rebecca Buckwalter, a writer and political consultant who was blocked in June after responding to Trump's tweet that he would have had "ZERO chance winning WH" if he had relied on the "Fake News".

The lawsuit against Mr Trump and other White House officials stems from his decision to bar several online critics.

"This case requires us to consider whether a public official may, consistent with the First Amendment, "block" a person from his Twitter account in response to the political views that person has expressed, and whether the analysis differs because that public official is the President of the United States", writes Buchwald.

"The answer to both questions is no".

Digital rights advocates applauded the ruling as a victory for First Amendment rights on social media.

Trump blocked co-plaintiff Holly Figueroa O'Reilly a year ago after she tweeted a gif of Pope Francis glancing at Trump with (what seems) like a disapproving expression.

Trump can, however, "mute" users, meaning he would not see their tweets while they could still respond to his.

While neither Trump nor Scavino are allowed to block users, Buchwald did not order them to unblock users.

Other News

Trending Now

Stunning Aerial Footage Shows Overnight Eruption at Kilauea Volcano
He said doctors had to pick sharp, hardened fragments of lava out of the wound, but the prognosis is good for his friend. "That's why having lava flow across the well causes some uncertainties that have to be dealt with", he said.

Iran Stresses Syria Presence Legitimate: "No One Will Take Us Out"
He and his counterpart hailed the beginning of the "political process" in Syria amid an ongoing "fight against terrorism". Nearly all previous Israeli airstrikes on targets in Syria have been late at night or in the pre-dawn hours.

Iran's Khamenei criticizes USA over hard-line stance
The head of Iran's Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Ali Akbar Salehi said Iran is ready to return to the pre-nuclear deal era. They will pledge to avoid opening negotiations over Iran's ballistic missile program or actions in the Middle East.

Kelly sued for sexual battery, false imprisonment
Kelly's support, and it has rushed to judgment without the facts. "I love you because you remind me of them'". "Not at all... Kelly refused to take the bait, however, telling her: "I don't never talk about nothing, to nobody on the phone".

Ariana Grande marks anniversary of Manchester bomb attack
The royal joined the families of the victims, survivors, first responders, and other emergency workers. Buses in Manchester pulled over by the roadside, and MPs in the House of Commons stood in silence.

M&S to close 100 UK stores by 2022
Its clothing and home business is a particular focus of its transformation efforts. Among the closures, 21 have already shut and 14 have been announced today.

Neymar Returns To First Training
He said the Brazilian reserve is not expected to start training on the pitch with his teammates until the end of the week. Brazil fitness coach Fabio Mahseredjian has given the latest update on Neymar's fitness ahead of the World Cup .